English
Verbal hygiene is the set of normative practices that language users have about which linguistic practices should be preferred. In a parallel manner, we define mathematical hygiene as the set of normative discourses regulating mathematical practices. The project has three main goals : 1) to document mathematical hygiene phenomena, with a particular focus on the history of French mathematics, 2) to compare mathematical hygiene & verbal hygiene phenomena in France synchronically & diachronically, 3) to develop a new understanding of how verbal & mathematical hygiene phenomena arise using the psychology of reasoning. Studying normative discourses on mathematics in the way that sociolinguists study normative discourses on language will open the door to a more general theory of the social & cognitive aspects of both mathematical & linguistic behavior. Both grammarians & mathematicians formulate their preferences in normative terms. In grammar, prescriptivists promote one grammatical option over others. Descriptivists hold instead that it is problematic to insist on one such option. Sociolinguists have shown that these preferences & arguments for these choices are related to grammarians’ social identities & politics. In mathematics, a proof is called pure if it draws only on what is “close” or “intrinsic” to that theorem. Many mathematicians have argued for the value of pure proofs, while others argue for impurity. We will study significant parallels between arguments justifying linguistic practices like prescriptivism & arguments justifying mathematical practices like purity. Since verbal hygiene arguments vary with time period & social context, we will focus on France during the 17th, 20th & 21st centuries. In addition to historical work, we will conduct psychological experiments with grammarians & mathematicians to study how they arrive at their arguments.
