English
<< Background >>The recent pandemic has speeded up the processes of adaptation of mHealth solutions, or the implementation of the digital tools in many healthcare and social care (HC&SC) areas, but it also uncovered several obstacles that exist on the demand side of it. It includes, among others lack of overall digital competencies and specific eHealth knowledge within the healthcare and social care workforce, as well as a lack of VET adaptation to the increasing sectoral needs. On top of that, between-country differences expose even more gaps in this respect. In some countries like Poland, or Romania, the digital transformation of HC&SC services is still severely underdeveloped, while other countries (like France) for almost a decade have national strategies implementing the process.Adapting the HC&SC workforce to the new digital reality is a key VET activity, especially now, with the implementation of the new digital care tools. The aim of this project is to address the needs of HC&SC workforce and to equip the VET system with innovative educational tools and materials, that can help and support digital transformation in the HC&SC sectors through securing digital readiness and resilience of their workforce.<< Objectives >>The e4CARE project’s aim is to provide a one-of-a-kind innovative didactic inventory, which will fill the EU and national gaps in terms of digital competence shortages among healthcare and social care professionals in innovating the care model.The concrete objectives are to: - identify and map the digital care tools being created (but not necessarily used) in the healthcare and social care services during the last couple of years; -Identify and list the digital skills needed for the effective use of the digital tools, as well as assess the skills gap of the healthcare workforce in this respect; - create an educational innovative tools that would secure and increase healthcare and social care (potential) workforces’ digital competencies; - provide an online space for local, regional, and national healthcare and social care stakeholders to exchange best practices, build knowledge, gain educational materials and increase their awareness in this respect; - provide policymakers at the national and regional level with the solutions, best practices, and recommendations that can help them speed up the digitalization process of care provision more effectively without using unnecessary costs.<< Implementation >>Meeting 1: The launch meeting took place in March 2022 in Romania at the headquarters of the AOA Coordinator. The purpose of the meeting was to ensure a common vision of the project and a consensus and in-depth understanding of the PM tools and requirements (report format, cost tracking tools, internal communication procedures, Agency relations, etc.) Meeting 2 in September 2022 was held in Poland at the CASE headquarters in conjunction with the launch of PR2 so that partners were all on the same page and had a common vision of PR1 outcomes and a common approach toPR2. The 3rd meeting of April 2023 took place in France, at the AKSANTYS headquarters. The meeting took place during the implementation of PR3, so that the partners could adjust the validation process according to the intermediate results. Meeting 4: The final closing meeting was held in November 2023 in Greece at IDEC headquarters to close the project and prepare the dissemination and exploitation activities for the 2 years after the end of the project and to develop future activities between the partners.<< Results >>PR1: e4CARE Training CenterOpen Educational Resources (OER)The training center has been created (https://www.e4care.eu/). The goal of the training center is to create well-structured digital tools that will help health and social care practitioners learn about innovative digital solutions used in professional work that can make their work more effective. The platform has been created, is functional and is in continuous development. All materials uploaded to the platform are available in English, as well as in the languages of the partner countries: French, Polish, Greek and Romanian. Assuming a wide range of target audiences, people working in social work – doctors, nurses, nurses and nursing – inpatient and outpatient doctors, inpatient and outpatient nurses, as well as unit managers and students, and taking into account considering the large number of topics to be covered, the consortium made the decision to divide all materials produced and published in the Platform into the following categories: hospital care, ambulatory care, home care and residential care. The first two categories fall under the health care sector, while the other two fall under the social care sector. They can also be considered as elements of long-term care (LTC), being strongly developed in some European countries, due to the aging of the population. Given that the health, social care and LTC sectors are not unified in the partner countries, the consortium partners agreed that this division would be the easiest to use and understand for HC and SC practitioners. Moreover, given the fact that the activities that were implemented in the project, as well as the training materials, are complex in nature, the Training Hub was divided into categories of knowledge to be created. Accordingly: - The Training Hub includes sections dedicated to digital solutions used in different parts of the HC and SC sectors: (https://www.e4care.eu/residential-care/) Each tool has its own website, it is described in an easy way to use and is easy to open on mobile devices. 60 tools have been created in 5 languages. The course part includes the training materials, which were based on the digital skills needs analysis questionnaire of people in the HC and SC sectors; - Community side - In order to effectively respond to the needs of HC and SC stakeholders, a special questionnaire was created that analyzes the digital skills of the workforce (https://www.e4care.eu/survey/). The survey is available in 5 languages. Each response was automatically recorded and statistics are automatically presented at the end of the survey. 226 people answered. The report summarizing the findings has been published. Based on this, the PR3 training materials were created. The Hub has been tested and validated based on 325 survey responses received by all 6 partners from both professionals and stakeholders. The survey was about the usefulness, attractiveness and user-friendly features of the Hub. Based on the answers, we made a post-test synthesis report based on the analysis of the feedback of the target group. Based on the reports, Result Leader – Aksantys made the changes suggested by the respondents. Considering the translation problems of specific medical terms and the impossibility of testing and validating PR1 in the absence of materials from PR2, the Partners decided to postpone the deadline for the completion of this result to 14.04.2023 (compared to the original 14.02.2023). Degree of completion of the result: 100%.PR2: Inventarul Didactic e4HealthMapping, review of scientific literatureAs a result, CASE provided the questionnaire needed to assess the digital skills gaps within HC&SC professionals, as well as the skills needs to use the tools effectively. All partners translated it into national languages and distributed the questionnaire among HC&SC institutions and stakeholders. The assessment of skills gaps among HC&SC professionals was a necessary step for the preparation of materials and a customized training plan in the following parts of the project - PR3. As part of the Desk Research - Identifying New Digital Models of Care, all partners mapped and presented the information gathered at country, regional and sector level. Regarding the skills needs analysis, Aksantys created the online interactive questionnaire and translated it into four project languages. We created the analytical tool, which allows the presentation of statistics. The partners were responsible for collecting questionnaire information from national stakeholders. New models and digital tools of care are being created (but not necessarily implemented) in HC and SC institutions. - Each partner identified the digital care models and tools created in HC and SC institutions and provided the leader with the list of digital tools - Based on more than 200 tools provided and shared by partners, CASE checked the correctness and selected a list of 60 digital tools for further development and inclusion in the e4CARE Inventory - Using a template and task guidelines, I prepared descriptions for the chosen tools. Each partner developed 10 digital tools for use in the health and social care sectors.Link RO: https://www.e4care.eu/ro/solutii/Link EN: https://www.e4care.eu/solutions/Link FR: https://www.e4care.eu/fr/solutions/Link PL: https://www.e4care.eu/pl/rozwiazania/Link GR: https://www.e4care.eu/el/%ce%bb%cf%8d%cf%83%ce%b5%ce%b9%cf%82/The tools described in this way have been translated by each partner into the language of their country. As the manager of the OEP, Aksantys created 60 additional subpages to upload all educational information to the Platform. The partners were responsible for the final language check. - Based on the model proposed by CASE, the Partners prepared the test and evaluation plan and questionnaire questions to approach the HC&SC workers to gain knowledge about the skill needs of the sector. It was distributed to both professionals and non-project stakeholders for PR2 testing and validation. Testing and Validation proceeded according to the originally proposed schedule: Askantys created the validation of the OEP questionnaire and the Partners distributed it to professionals and stakeholders. Using the answers to the questionnaires, each Partner submitted a post-test summary report based on the analysis of the feedback of the target group. Based on the reports, Result Leader – CASE made the necessary changes. There were no changes from the originally proposed implementation schedule. PR2 completion rate: 100%.PR3: e4CARE stock of e-learning materialsLearning / teaching / training material – ToolkitThe implementation of PR3 is the sustainable response to the challenges presented in the first part of this proposal and has led to the creation of a truly innovative stock of e-learning materials within the VET system to support the HC&SC workforce in their daily work.Link RO: https://www.e4care.eu/ro/cursuri/Link EN: https://www.e4care.eu/courses/Link FR: https://www.e4care.eu/fr/cours/Link PL: https://www.e4care.eu/pl/kursy/Link GR: https://www.e4care.eu/el/%ce%bc%ce%b1%ce%b8%ce%ae%ce%bc%ce%b1%cf%84%ce%b1/The target group for the training materials includes HC&SC professionals and the workforce, who every day might use digital care tools with their patients. The VET system in the HC&SC sector does not provide a stock of learning materials, which is a direct response to the digital transformation of care tools in the HC&SC sector. The detailed needs analyzes implemented in PR2 constituted a starting point for the preparation of educational tools in this regard. The partners agreed, when preparing the proposal, on the preliminary list of topics covering the educational stock, in response to the new digital models of care, to create microfiches with instructions on how to use specific tools and supported by youtube. video whenever possible. 36 microfiches were created in response to the identification of digital skills needs to use the tools, 6 fit-for-purpose e-learning courses were prepared, aimed at increasing digital skills, teaching digital skills and improving the efficiency of using digital care tools . They are created within the Moodle 3.2 educational form with improved navigation functionality. To address the knowledge gaps of HC&SC professionals regarding the implementation of new models of care, best practices and policy solutions are presented in the form of infographics, video blogs or educational materials. According to the Public Health Services Division of the WHO, the following elements are included in this element: monitoring, prevention, primary health care, disorders, diseases, LTC. All elements comprise several interconnected elements in one well-structured and easy-to-use tool. This PR remains available for wider promotion and sharing activities beyond this funding, thus ensuring the sustainability of the results and their integration for use in multilingual versions by VET systems across Europe. The e4CARE stock is highly innovative: a) it is the first stock of publicly available e-learning materials offered in VET to train them on the digital use of new care models used in the health and social care sectors during the pandemic; b) it is the first e-learning tool that offers direct solutions adapted to the purpose of the digital skills gap between professionals; c) the stock structure provides an easy-to-use formula and cross-sectoral combination of knowledge. In addition, the created Validation Methodology and the evaluation questionnaire allowed the evaluation of e4CARE PR3 from different angles, ensured its universality and allowed a more extensive use of the result at the end of the project. Impact: Due to the broad target group of this project and the diverse list of potential beneficiaries, the e4CARE Inventory not only enables VET students and professionals in the health and social care sector to be better equipped and empowered in the knowledge of digital use. Of the new models of care, it will fill the gap between their fit-for-purpose digital skills. The impact is expected at different levels, as the multilingual version is available without restrictions on the e4CARE Hub and falls within the EU priorities. Portability: Multilingual versions are available for free. Transferability is further ensured by the consortium structure, which includes recognized institutions in their countries and regions with extensive international contacts, which allows for extensive dissemination and transfer activities. PR3 completion rate: 100%
