English
This project addresses the relation between global and local aspects of a shift in governance by gathering and analyzing patterns of language use in the global circulation and local instantiation of Integrated Water Resource Management (IWRM). IWRM can be understood as a prospective shift in governance that has been circulated through the discursive practices of a variety of academic, NGO and international financial institutional networks. Since the nineties, IWRM has attained an increasing presence in new media such as the web. A variety of nations are currently attempting to implement it locally through the development of IWRM National Plans. Underlying these efforts is a claim that, if realized, IWRM will constitute a significant shift in the social, political, and scientific aspects of water management on a global scale. A turn to participatory governance has been an especially crucial aspect of the shift. While IWRM principles such as participation, sustainability, and efficiency have been effective in differentiating it from so-called traditional water management paradigms, expressions of these principles lack the detail that would specify how to achieve IWRM on the ground in particular regional settings. The semantic content of IWRM is strong at the level of principles to be achieved, but weak at the level of prescriptive specifications for how to achieve them. Such principles assume a different shape depending on the constraints of social and environmental conditions. In attempting to write and implement national IWRM plans, local actors face enormous complexity as they instantiate principles of participation, sustainability, and efficiency in their specific contexts. IWRM Plans do not only have to be instantiated through activities on the ground. These activities on the ground must (1) meet the necessary exigencies of the local context, including the conditions of legitimacy that are maintained by the existing state while (2) they must be marked or made recognizable as instantiations of IWRM. There is therefore a dual challenge embedded in the global circulation and local instantiation of this shift in governance. These processes are intertwined, and cannot be accounted for by theoretical approaches to diffusion that assume that the globalization of a governance form can be realized only through the concrete reproduction of pre-specified institutional activities of different local settings. This project examines the role of texts in the diffusion process, by hypothesizing that discursive practices mediate the relationship between policy models and the institutional activities that they are meant to structure. Diffusion is therefore studied from the standpoint of the texts that are (a) used to circulate IWRM as a globalizable institutional model, and (b) used to represent local activities as instances of IWRM. They are examined here at the level of communications. We will conduct a comparative analysis of IWRM discourses on the web and in the national IWRM plans of two countries. That comparison will be supplemented by two case studies of the two countries in terms of the institutional and environmental conditions in which their respective plan-writing processes unfold.
