English
Today’s urgent issue is how to build inclusive societies in which disabled people can equally participate. Yet the drive towards equality also creates tensions. Hearing loss and deafness are a prominent example: while physicians aim to remedy these disabilities, this paradoxically fosters the connotation of disability as pathological. Scholars have therefore dismissed the medical approach, arguing that disability should be seen as a social construct: impairment lies in discriminating economic, cultural, and political attitudes. This ‘social model’, however, has been criticised for ignoring the real predicament many disabled experience. This project argues that a historical approach can help solve this binary opposition between medical and social understandings of disability. It investigates why the perception and social status of the deaf dramatically changed in the eighteenth century. Whereas in medieval times deafness was seen as divine punishment, leaving the deaf isolated from society, by 1700 sign language and speech therapies were developed. I hypothesise that it was thanks to early medical studies in hearing and hearing loss that the perception of deafness radically changed. The project builds on recent scholarship in deaf history and disability studies, but is innovative in combining these insights with the method of critical medical humanities.
